Culture of Abuse in Irish Society

11 Feb

2009 is a year that will face scrutiny, study but will seldom be lamented. Following its New Years chimes and cheers it brought with it the greatest economic and social upheaval seen worldwide in generations. The collapse of banking systems, credit systems, building and construction were all felt on a global scale and with particular frenzy in Ireland, which hitherto had been the smug centre-fold of a booming society in pictorial.

Along with the collapse of its banks, building sites and high living Ceann Comhairles Ireland suffered a relapse of failure of a different kind – the collapse of its moral and ethical responsibility to its children and those which were most vulnerable in its society. The damming and blisteringly horrific reports of the Commission to Enquire into Child Abuse in Ireland and the Dublin Diocesan Report brought to the surface the rotten core of Ireland’s institutional schools and the suffering inflicted within. ‘A Culture of Abuse’ has become a phrase synonymous with public reaction to the evidence presented by the investigation committee. This culture has extra resonance when superimposed on the abuse of power, expenses and trust that radiated from Leinster House during the Boom years like a fog on a November night.

From the early twentieth century to its closing years those who suffered at the hands of the authorities of Ireland’s institutional schools were preyed upon by clergy that were protected within a society of containment and secrecy. Bruises were blindly ignored, deaf ears were turned to cries and complaints and shame and fear were used as weapons against the children who were “tempting and causing sin against them”. The Catholic Church was itself Arch Primate in Ireland in the early and mid twentieth century. Just behind and to its right hand was a state government who allowed this culture of abuse to permeate and breed. The abuse against children grew worse, more blatant and the secrecy grew likewise.

Those who entered Ireland’s industrial schools did so ‘voluntarily’, by family intervention and by intervention of Gardai and the courts. While a state and church allowed such abuse to continue by not investigating complaints and moving the guilty abusers to new stations, there still remained a self-imposed and maintained smoke screen by an Irish people who were drilled to bow to the mitre. It has been reported how communities and family members were aware to some extent of abuses carried out at Ireland’s Institutional schools and Laundries.

Now, in the immediate aftershock of publication of the Commission to Enquire into Child Abuse in Ireland report and the Dublin Diocesan Report and also the Ferns Diocesan report the evidence is startling but evidence it is. When one stares blankly and in disbelief at the front page of newspaper report or television documentary and asks “Why”, perhaps it would be better to ask “How”. The inmates of Ireland’s Institutional schools and Laundries had families, friends, neighbours and public representatives who did not act bravely enough, strongly enough or with any deliberate speed in response to this abuse. The initial response to these reports has been a blank expression that includes genuine anger, frustration and also disbelief that this happened ‘on their watch’. Well, it did. Reaction in the 1950’s, 1960’s, 1970’s, 1980’s or 1990’s did arrive in some shape and form into the mainstream consciousness, but this reaction was not always heard, viewed or adhered to in time or at all.

The artistic response to abuse in Ireland came when a people and nation were not fully able to comprehend what was ongoing and in their midst. Even still today, reaction to abuse does not always readily afford a tangible realisation of responsibility by public representatives, clergy, bishops or whoever did not intervene. Distance of time does not verify a distance of responsibility or lessen the heinousness of the act.  The memory of those abused in the home or in Institutional care has been explored through a myriad of cultural means. Through theatre, novels, short stories, visual arts, installations and television documentaries, abuse in Ireland was presented to the people to be claimed by their own responsibility, their lack of action but also thus allowing for future action.

Irish theatre is recognisable for being acutely aware of its social responsibility as a cultural and social barometer. It is a particularly visceral performer in informing the public and creating debate and response. On 30th January 1961, The Abbey Theatre produced a world premiere of The Evidence I Shall Give, a play written by Richard Johnson, a district court judge in Kerry, whose son, Richard Jnr, would later succeed to the position of President of the High Court in Ireland. The Evidence I Shall Give is a court room drama telling the story of a young girl who is committed to an Institutional residence as she is considered beyond family care. The play features a heavy-handed Mother Superior who tries to dominate the courtroom proceedings as she does the events within her convent. The constant battle between legal, moral and spiritual responsibility towards the young girl and the indifferent treatment by the Judge to the place of the case is frustratingly all too real in the wake of the recent Commission reports. The triviality with which the girl’s well being is dealt by the State, via the Judge, and by the Church, via the Mother Superior, is damming of the lack of forthright tackling of abuse and the legislation that defended a community to remand unruly children in ‘the protection’ of  Institutional schools.

This play secured an initial performance run of 42 performances; a considerable amount considering this was the first professionally produced play by Johnson at any theatre in Dublin. The play returned to the Abbey stage, interestingly by public demand, in July, August, September and October of 1961 with the total number of productions reaching 126 throughout the year. Basically, this means the play was on stage at the Abbey for a third of the calendar year. More interestingly, it would take nearly fifty years to the month, April 2010, for this play to be revived by the Abbey, a theatre which is not exactly opposed to reproducing works from its past repertoire.  The fact that this play was produced at the Abbey at all is worth consideration. It is, after all, the State theatre of Ireland. The fact that it chose to tackle the evidence of abuse in Ireland long before there was any evidence in the public domain did show a courageous step at a time when the Abbey was under the direction of Ernest Blythe.  The play highlighted the flaws of legislation that did not recognise the abuse permeating within Irish society that did not protect its children and forced those legislators such as Johnson who were aware but frustrated at these inadequacies to turn to cultural means to make the public aware of the evidence and what it could show.

It would be another ten years before another major work investigating abuse in Ireland would be produced on stage.  In August 1971, Journal of a Hole was produced at the Project Arts Centre in Dublin by the SLOT players. This group (St. Lawrence O’Toole’s – the parish of the group’s members) would include the emerging greats in Irish theatre and film such as Jim and Peter Sheridan and Neil Jordan. This play is centred on the abuse suffered by those children resident in Artane Industrial School in Dublin. The play name is a pun on the book Journal of a Soul, the autobiography of Pope John XXIII, who was pope from 1958-63, (covering the period in which Richard Johnson wrote and produced his play The Evidence I Shall Give) This play was a new production on a professional stage within a radical centre and departure within the Irish arts scene. The Project Arts Centre, founded in 1966 and originally only as a three-week project, would nurture and develop young Irish artists, allowing them an outlet and audience for their work they would seldom else get. In conversation with the plays director Peter Sheridan he describes the public reaction to Journal:

“We had a plant in the audience, a fella dressed as a brother who objected to the play at the finale. This as you can imagine caused a great discussion to evolve. Kane archer, the Irish Times critic made reference to the audience member, unaware that he was a plant”.

 The plot of the play would centre on the experience of a member of SLOT players at Artane School and the grim experiences he recounted. Sheridan would describe them vividly:

“I remember two scenes every well. One where he (Robert) crosses the white line the in the playground – it was divided in two between the junior boys and the senior boys – and it was strictly forbidden to cross the line. Robert chases after a ball and the brother catches him. He digs him on the nose and it starts to bleed. He sends him off to wash it at the yard tap. He comes back to show the brother. There is still a drop of blood on his face. He gets another dig for his trouble. That level of physical cruelty was endemic in Artane but it was also prevalent in national schools, too. Serious physical abuse was a daily thing and there was an extraordinary tolerance of this among the Irish population.

The real deal of Artane was being taken away from your parents. So it operated effectively as a prison for children. Robert was sent there for mitching. Others were sent for stealing or breaking the law. It housed a population of orphans too.

The other unforgettable scene was the punishment for bed wetting. The offenders were made to stand by their beds if they persisted in wetting. They were roused during the night. If wet, they were hauled from their beds and kept standing all night. Chronic offenders were then made to wear a nappy and they had to come in to class in the nappy. This must have been humiliating in the extreme”.

This play was an indication by a new generation of artists and theatre professionals that they were not following on in the shadow of their past generation by bowing to the smokescreen and culture of secrecy that had lain forcibly around abuse in Irish society. Further works by Sheridan such as No Entry premiered at the Project Arts Centre on 16 March 1976 and again tackled the prevailing violence perpetrated against young people in Ireland. The fact that the Project Arts Centre was staging these works is striking as just over ten years previously the state theatre, the Abbey theatre was staging works investigating institutional and clerical abuse. These ten years had also shown that these works had changed from being a an expose piece, i.e. highlighting for the first time a cultural depiction of abuse, to what would become in the early and mid 1970s a reactionary piece in taking to a new level what had previously briefly broken through the culture of containment.

A group of young, energetic and socially aware artists active in 1970’s and 1980’s were at times in conflict and contrast with the theme and tone of work produced and also at odds with the audience that attended their works. Mannix Flynn was an inmate at Artane Industrial School in Dublin. He later became an actor and artist and was part of the Project Arts Centre troupe and was a cast member of the Journal of a Hole production. Flynn would become an important artist whose work focused on his memory and experience of abuse and time spent in Artane Industrial School. His works include theatre, visual art, installations and writing and produce a body of work that is instinctive of the necessary cultural response to the gamut of containment and coercion in Irish society.

 In conversation with Flynn he speaks passionately, personally and openly about his work, his art and why he refuses to produce art simply ‘for art’s sake’ or to suit the style and ‘safe’ art often produced for commercial reasons. The challenge of his work, he says, is ‘how you reflect on something that is not cultural to begin with, by cultural means’?  He speaks of class divides and being recognised as not just an artist but as ‘the artist that was abused’. Flynn chooses to produce the work he does not in order to shock or grate. If this is a response from an audience member then that, he says, ‘is down to the individual comfort levels and own security’. In Artane, comfort levels did not exist. Extallations such as Remains Unknown and installations such as Padded Cell provoke a public discourse that has been remarkably silent regarding a cultural response to abuse.

Flynn also discusses how the reports published by the Commission to Enquire into Child Abuse and Dublin Diocesan reports colloquially came to be called The Ryan Report and Murphy Report respectively. “This diminishes the impact of the reports considerably. The media have distorted the report titles leaving them with an attached personality of which it was not intended to have.” They are reports to investigate Abuse. Now they are simply ‘Ryan’ and ‘Murphy’, again hiding the word abuse from the mouths and eyes of Irish people. We are afraid to think and speak this word, acknowledging the role played by those in facilitating fear and containment in society.

Along with the artists and staff of Far Cry Productions Flynn has produced an extremely strong piece of performance entitled James X. This one man performance depicts the story of James O’Neill who now in his forties stands before the High Court to testify to the ill-treatment by agents of church and state. The interplay between the written accounts, archive documents and personal oral testimony from James presents not just the ordeal that children suffered within residential schools but also an indication of the failures and collective cruelties of the Irish church, state, people and government. James is presented with a file that tracks his entire life but this represents him as a number and not a child with rights and needs irrespective of class and entitlement. The file is representive of how the State views James, as a figure within a repressive system and not as soul that was mistreated and forgotten.

The Abbey Theatre has come forward with a Spring program entitled The Darkest Corner dealing specifically with abuse. Thomas Kilroy’s commissioned play Christ Deliver Us, a play inspired by German dramatist Frank Wedekind’s 1891 piece, Spring Awakening tackles the Irish society that in the 1950’s was often judged to be patrimonial and introvert in its familial duties.

Mary Raftery, the journalist who shattered so much of the silence and broke down so much of the secrecy regarding abuse with her documentary research including States of Fear and Suffer the Little Children, has produced a new piece called  No Escape. This program also includes the aforementioned works The Evidence I Shall Give and James X by Mannix Flynn.

David Scott, director and teacher, has produced a work with his own theatre group Company D, entitled Skinners which also presents a middle aged former inmate of an industrial school who stands before the Redress Board and recounts his experience. The play written by Michael Kennedy and Directed by Scott is cleverly produced using flash back sequences to truly deafening and bruising scenes of violence suffered by a young Michael Cleere. The devise of having the barrister and judge of the redress board take on the robes of Brothers and priests and with it a vengeful and insecure fury during the flashback scenes is extremely effective in signifying the ongoing frustration felt by those going before the courts and battling legislation.

In early 2010, commercial collapse and banking crises still lie entrenched on our media headlines. The Commissions to Enquire into Child Abuse in Ireland, The Dublin Diocesan Report, the Ferns Report, the Redress Board and the fact of a lack of official response regarding the equally horrific experience of Ireland’s Magdalenes, continues to highlight the dumb mouth with which abuse in Ireland is dealt with. However, there appears to be a glimmer of hope. There seems now a concentrated and relevent response and reaction to this abuse. Ireland’s artists, actors, writers and journalists are battling a formidable foe in the form of a culture of abuse that has ingrained itself in the Irish psyche. ‘Don’t rock the boat’ and ‘for the good of the State and people’ are ideas which have so obviously failed the children of Ireland.

Cultural and artistic means are a forceful way of informing, educating and provoking a discourse on change of action to prevent ever such a lack of care from happening again. If we are to take anything from the evidence presented from the Commission to Enquire into Child Abuse in Ireland and the Dublin Diocesan Report then it is to take responsibility for what has happened and remove the culture of abuse that was evident in parishes, courts, homes and schools throughout Ireland.

In the foreword to James X (1993) Mannix Flynn describes James, “standing firmly in the present, he re-enacts the past and, in the process, he learns to care about and love himself. This, he says, is his reclaiming mission. Its objective is ‘to thine own self be true’. The truth will set you free. “


Posted by on February 11, 2010 in Culture, Theatre, Uncategorized


Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

17 responses to “Culture of Abuse in Irish Society

  1. Tuka Jani

    August 6, 2012 at 7:19 pm

    Gracias for moving me to go look up my own investigation.

    Yours was way more thought out than mine.

  2. orthodontics insurance

    September 13, 2012 at 12:48 am

    Hello there! This article could not be written much better!
    Going through this post reminds me of my previous roommate!
    He continually kept talking about this. I most certainly will send this post to him.
    Fairly certain he will have a very good read. Thanks
    for sharing!

  3. Chelsey

    February 15, 2013 at 6:13 am

    However, over 18% of US grownups experience more extreme types of Anxiety Disorder. First generally there tend to be biological otherwise medical reasons, then there are emotional aspects. whenever someone experiences a powerful heart beats suddenly and additionally breathing quickens.

  4. Clarence

    February 28, 2013 at 4:42 pm

    “Culture of Abuse in Irish Society | Staged Reaction” Sun Shades truly makes me imagine a tiny bit more.
    I actually cherished every single component of this post.
    Thanks for the post ,Angelia

  5. Jarrod

    April 1, 2013 at 11:29 am

    Hi, I want to subscribe for this weblog to get most recent updates, so where can i do
    it please help out.

  6. dining table sets

    April 17, 2013 at 7:17 am

    That can be a type of state representation in ancient Chinese tradition.
    So it doesn’t matter the direction of the dining area however you need to surely
    fill it because of the correct furniture in
    order to get the experience of rich and wealthy.
    Keep in mind that floor space is essential to be able for your and also your very own guests to try to be seated at the granite top
    dining table in the area.A table what kind of you don’t usually see as part of the dining area is actually perhaps a Cocktail or Coffee Table.

  7. childrens ralph lauren

    May 12, 2013 at 11:52 pm

    Despite overweight evidence which he in fact raped
    a policewoman presented to protect his house, he was acquitted
    expected to lack of evidence. eventually, it might not be bad to send the scouter to the workplace, to see exactly what the people gown like.
    Pay for Ralph Lauren pas cher or dresses through out the internet
    when having these products put in spot these days, keep as part of mind, available the fact significant resolution is usually to apparent the actual
    apparel for you to dried up Ralph Lauren.

  8. dining table height

    May 29, 2013 at 7:23 am

    It might also feel something that can last years and
    also years and also become a particular heirloom to be passed away right down to future generations.
    Taking the leaf from the table or perhaps adding definitely one,
    is also yet another good solution, it might completely change
    the sizes of your dining area. Alternatively of maintaining a perfect granite top dining
    table, you may get the glass cut in an inverted arc outline during the sides.

    They have a powerful eye catching and a particular extremely creative look,
    and that is aided by the master handcraft’s elegant wood carving of a variety of designs around the Dining Table Antiques.

  9. Lac.Org

    June 12, 2013 at 10:56 pm

    This definitely will go a long way in further enriching your very own knowledge prior to you venture out on your own welding business.
    For damp Welding or perhaps Underwater Welding, the approach is performed underneath water and that is
    directly out to the damp style. Other welding as part of the
    Raleigh area falls inside the fabrication region.
    If you are really a California college student because becoming a welder, or
    perhaps simply wish to learn advanced welding skill for your very own store or operate, enrolling as part of welding class is a smart chose.

    Moreover these are typically available for jobs of every nature that may vary according to the field in which these are typically needed.

  10. raspberry ketone

    June 16, 2013 at 12:03 pm

    Thank you for the good writeup. It in truth was a entertainment account it.
    Glance complex to far delivered agreeable from you! However, how can
    we be in contact?

  11. tattoo names

    June 19, 2013 at 4:17 pm

    I really love your blog.. Pleasant colors & theme. Did you
    build this web site yourself? Please reply back as I’m hoping to create my very own site and would love to learn where you got this from or exactly what the theme is named. Kudos!

  12. How To Lose A Stone in a Week

    July 29, 2013 at 1:53 am

    Have you ever thought about including a little bit
    more than just your articles? I mean, what you say is fundamental and all.
    However imagine if you added some great visuals
    or videos to give your posts more, “pop”! Your content is excellent but with images and video clips, this website
    could certainly be one of the most beneficial in its niche.

    Terrific blog!

  13. ralphlaurens

    August 4, 2013 at 3:59 pm

    Its fun to walk in a boutique to shop for
    clothes with impeccable style. The problem is
    most individuals have much more important things to attend to that is why they do
    not have time to shop. There is no requirement to fret though because internet
    shopping has made things simpler for you. The most recent RL collection are made accessible in
    the online boutique site. The items have been organized by
    line and collection so it will be simple for you to explore and
    select. With this, you still be capable to shop even if
    you are swarmed with tasks in the office or home.

  14. realestateinflorida

    October 17, 2013 at 5:08 pm

    hello, i’m so pleased that i found your web site I will be sharing this!
    – real estate 08260 is a passion of mine and and your
    “Culture of Abuse in Irish Society | Staged Reaction” article
    is without doubt really good work.
    Keep it up! I’ll definately be back again soon!

  15. Free Money System Review Software

    July 7, 2014 at 8:01 pm

    I do not even understand how I ended up right here, but I believed this post was great.

    I don’t realize who you are but definitely you’re going to a well-known blogger
    when you are not already. Cheers!

  16. escort Fort Lauderdale

    July 8, 2014 at 12:04 am

    Pretty great post. I simply stumbled upon your weblog and wished to mention that I’ve really enjoyed surfing around
    your weblog posts. In any case I will be subscribing in your rss feed
    and I am hoping you write again soon!

  17. ฝันเห็นงู

    September 27, 2014 at 11:23 pm

    A fantasize is manything that we humans have a deep shemage events.

    While the draft after a secret dinner are not yet able to elaborate more
    clearly. Today, prosperity has come to human liveliness, but
    she can\’t find an riposte to confirm, i understand, while the dream of the story events and cannot understand that the phenomenon occurred after the fai
    have relations with the imagine of a man, however.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: